| Title | Year (chronological order) | Director | Playwright |
| Lysistrata | 1969-01 | Stuart Gordon | Aristophanes |
| Woyzeck | 1969-02 | Joel Gersmann | Georg Buchner |
| Don Perimplin’s Love with Belsa In The Garden (double feature paired with Wreckers Incopated) | 1969-03 (August 7–10 Thurs – Sun) | Based on Federico García Lorca‘s Don Periplim | |
| Wreckers Incopated (double feature paired with Don Perimplin’s Love with Belsa In The Garden) | 1969-03 (August 7–10 Thurs – Sun) | Bill Reese | Peter Manesis |
| The Exception and the Rule (double feature paired with The Madness of Lady Bright) | 1969-04 (mid-August) | Cind Fritz | Bertolt Brecht |
| The Madness of Lady Bright (double feature paired with The Exception and the Rule) | 1969-04 (mid-August) | Cind Fritz | Lanford Wilson |
| Evergreen | 1969-05 (late September) | Henry (Hank) Haslach | Henry (Hank) Haslack |
| Wreckers Incopated | 1969-06 (late September) | Bill Reese | Peter Manesis |
| Dutchman | 1969-07 | Charles Wise | Leroi Jones |
| Solemn Communion: A Panic Ceremony | 1969-08 | Joel Gersmann | Fernande Arrabal |
| Orison (paired with Dr. Kheal and Notes From A Vietnamese Phrase Book as a triple feature titled The Hypotenuse of Angst) | 1969-09 | Joel Gersmann | Fernande Arrabal |
| Dr. Kheal (paired with Orison and Notes From A Vietnamese Phrase Book as a triple feature titled The Hypotenuse of Angst) | 1969-09 | Joel Gersmann | Maria Irene Fornes |
| Notes From A Vietnamese Phrase Book (paired with Orison and Dr. Kheal as a triple feature titled The Hypotenuse of Angst) | 1969-09 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Sequence | 1969-10 (December) | Bill Reese | Bill Reese |
| One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest | 1970-01 | Dennis Coleman | Ken Kesey |
| Contempt of the Conspiracy 8 | 1970-02 | Robert Seder | Robert Seder |
| Troilus and Cressida | 1970-03 | Joel Gersmann | William Shakespeare |
| The Sirens of Titan | 1970-04 | Bill Reese | Kurt Vonnegut |
| A Dream Play | 1970-05 | Joel Gersmann | August Strindberg |
| The Junk Show | 1970-06 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Junk Show II | 1970-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Difficult Hour (II) (paired with Fool’s Flight as a double feature titled The Ozark Doubleheader) | 1970-08 | Joel Gersmann | Par Lagerkvist |
| Fool’s Flight (paired with The Difficult Hour [II] as a double feature titled The Ozark Doubleheader) | 1970-08 | Louis Rackoff | Imre Goldstein |
| Peer Gynt | 1971-01 | Joel Gersmann | Henrik Ibsen |
| The Penal Colony | 1971-02 | Robert (Bob) Seder | Franz Kafka |
| Woyzeck (re-staged, modified from the 1969 production) | 1971-03 | Joel Gersmann | Georg Buchner |
| Normal Love | 1971-04 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Murdock’s Rock Palace | 1971-05 | Henry (Hank) Haslack | Henry (Hank) Haslack |
| The Attic Angel (paired with A Dog Sled as a double feature titled The Eggplant That Ate Chicago) | 1971-06 | Norman Caplan | Rod Clark |
| A Dog Sled (paired with The Attic Angel as a double feature titled The Eggplant That Ate Chicago) | 1971-07 | Chris Morris | Mike Baron |
| We Sinned Too Young and Cried Too Late, or Passion’s Willful Curse Caused Our Downfall (paired with The Awakening of Amy Brant as a double feature titled Eat Me Tonight) | 1971-07 | Fred Murray | Fred Murray |
| The Awakening of Amy Brant (paired with We Sinned Too Young and Cried Too Late, or Passion’s Willful Curse Caused Our Downfall as a double feature titled Eat Me Tonight) | 1971-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Hot Wankel | 1971-08 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| A Night at an Inn (paired with The Only Jealousy of Emer as a double feature titled The Flaxen Crock) | 1971-09 | John Moe | Lord Dunsany |
| The Only Jealousy of Emer (paired with A Night at an Inn as a double feature titled The Flaxen Crock) | 1971-09 | John Moe | William Butler Yeats |
| Alpha Kappa | 1972-01 | Joel Gersmann | Marjorie Paradis |
| A Midsummer Night’s Dream | 1972-02 | Joel Gersmann | William Shakespeare |
| The Cavern | 1972-03 | Joel Gersmann | Jean Anouilh |
| Tortured Heart | 1972-04 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| King of Siam | 1972-05 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| A Christmas Carol | 1972-06 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann & BST |
| The David Cassidy Story | 1973-01 | Weasel Schuler (Cynthia Schider) | Weasel Schuler (Cynthia Schider) |
| Metamorphasis | 1973-02 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Big Ditch | 1973-03 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| West Side Story | 1973-04 | Weasel Schuler (Cynthia Schider) | Arthur Laurents |
| Richard III | 1974-01 | Joel Gersmann | William Shakespeare |
| Madame Butterfly | 1974-02 | Joel Gersmann | David Belasco |
| The Song of Bernadette | 1974-03 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Good Woman of Mazomanie | 1974-04 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Junior Miss | 1975-01 | Joel Gersmann | Jerome Chodorov |
| Noah’s Flood | 1975-02 | Joel Gersmann | Christoffer Morris & Joel Gersmann |
| The Revisionist Gas (paired with The Applicant and Trouble in the Works as a triple feature titled The Big Sandwich) | 1975-03 | Thom King | Rod Clark |
| The Applicant (paired with The Revisionist Gas and Trouble in the Works as a triple feature titled The Big Sandwich) | 1975-03 | Thom King | Harold Pinter |
| Trouble in the Works (paired with The Revisionist Gas and Trouble in the Works as a triple feature titled The Big Sandwich) | 1975-03 | Thom King | Harold Pinter |
| Nancy Drew | 1975-04 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Gone With the Wind | 1976-01 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Julius Caesar | 1976-02 | Joel Gersmann | William Shakespeare |
| Marjorie Morningstar | 1976-03 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Fear Strikes Out | 1977-01 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann & Gary Alyesworth |
| Mildred Pierce | 1977-02 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| My Son John | 1977-03 opened April 15, 1977 | Joel Gersmann | Roger Grodsky & Joel Gersmann |
| Tarzan and the Jewels of Opar | 1977-04 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Self Accusation (double feature paired with Waiting for Lefty) | 1977-05 | Howard Waxman | Peter Handke |
| Waiting for Lefty (double feature paired with Self Accusation) | 1977-05 | Howard Waxman | Clifford Odets |
| Smoke (double feature paired with The Cardboard Camel) | 1977-06 – Sept 9, 1977 | Rod Clark | Rod Clark |
| The Cardboard Camel (double feature paired with Smoke) | 1977-06 – Sept 9, 1977 | Rod Clark | Rod Clark |
| Fear Strikes Out | 1977-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann & Gary Alyesworth |
| A Feast of Snakes | 1977-08 – October 14, 1977 | Charles Valenza | Charles Valenza |
| The Golem | 1977-09 – November 4, 1977 | Joel Gersmann | H. Lievick |
| The Great Little Christmas Show | 1977-10 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Beer / Tower of Baraboo | 1978-02 – February 9, 1978 | Charles Valenza | Charles Valenza |
| Home Sweet Home | 1978-03 – March 10, 1978 | Gary Alyesworth & Jeanette Sarmiento | Gary Alyesworth & Jeanette Sarmiento |
| I Want to Live | 1978-04 – April 1978 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Romeo and Juliet | 1978-05 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Punk Rock | 1978-06 – June, 1978 | Howard Waxman | Howard Waxman |
| Desi Arnaz | 1978-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Chain Letter | 1978-08 | Rod Clark & Anne Biberman | Rod Clark |
| Action Comic | 1978-09 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Ramayana | 1979-01 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Who Did What When? | 1979-02 | Ada McAllister | Ada McAllister |
| Fear Strikes Out | 1979-03 – April 20–22 only | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann & Gary Alyesworth |
| It’s a Wonderful Life | 1979-04 – May 11 – June 17 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Marcus Whitman M.D. | 1979-05 | Gary Aylesworth | Joel Gersmann |
| The Book of Job | 1979-06 | Gary Aylesworth & Joel Gersmann | Gary Aylesworth & Joel Gersmann |
| The Maxwell House Demon | 1979-07 | Rod Clark | Rod Clark |
| Home Sweet Home | 1979-08 | Gary Alyesworth & Jeanette Sarmiento | Gary Alyesworth & Jeanette Sarmiento |
| Running | 1979-09 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Running | 1980-01 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Internal Injuries | 1980-02 | Ada McAllister | Ada McAllister |
| The House of Mystery | 1980-03 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Wholly Balls | 1980-04 | Gary Aylesworth | Gary Aylesworth |
| Favorite Son | 1980-05 – Aug 29 -Sept 14 | Marty Mulhern | Marty Mulhern |
| Feel Safe | 1980-06 | Rod Clark | Rod Clark |
| Dick Whittington’s Cat | 1980-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Houdini the Jew from Appleton | 1981-01 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Brother Animal | 1981-02 – May 8, 1981 | Gary Aylesworth | Gary Aylesworth |
| The Princess and the Shadow or Mama, What’s Love? | 1981-03 – | Ray Olderman | Ray Olderman |
| The Taming of the Shrew | 1981-04 | Nancy A. Phipps | William Shakespeare |
| The Wonderful World of Jacqueline Susanne | 1981-05 – September 18, 1981 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Unhinged! | 1981-06 | Glenn Miller | Glenn Miller |
| Clara Reeve | 1982-01 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Bertha Sister of the Road | 1982-02 | Ray Olderman | Star Olderman |
| Shadowland | 1982-03 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Signalized | 1982-04 | Adrienne Rabinowitz | Danielle Dresden |
| How to Improve Your Lover’s Performance | 1982-05 – Aug 27 – Oct 3 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Man Who Laughs | 1982-06 | Marty Mulhern | Marty Mulhern |
| The Day of the Triffids | 1982-07 – Dec 3 – Dec 19 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Big Expectations | 1983-01 | Star Olderman | Ray Olderman |
| The Passion of Passover | 1983-02 – Mar 18 – May 8 | Joel Gersmann, Choreography Donna Peckett, Music Direction Neil Peckett | Joel Gersmann |
| Hans Brinker | 1983-03 | Joel Gersmann, Choreography Donna Peckett, Music Direction Neil Peckett | Joel Gersmann |
| Might | 1983-04 | Bryn Magnus | Bryn Magnus |
| Bombs Away Enola Gay | 1983-05 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Hans Brinker | 1983-06 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Peter Pan | 1983-07 | Frank Furillo | Danielle Dresden |
| Ligeia Has Risen From The Grave | 1984-01 | Frank Furillo | Rod Clark |
| The Jesus Gang | 1984-02 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Inside the Double Helix | 1984-03 | Danielle Dresden | Danielle Dresden |
| Light My Fire | 1984-04 – June 22 – July 29 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Ubik | 1984-05 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Packer Glory | 1984-06 | Tracy Will | Tracy Will |
| Miracle of the Dappled Rose | 1984-07 | Ray Olderman, Marjorie Pomper directed dance, Casper Sunn directed music | Ray Olderman |
| The Black Albatross | 1985-01 | Mark Peters | Mark Peters |
| Junk Mail | 1985-02 | Star Olderman | Star Olderman |
| Portage Potential | 1985-03 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Natural Hostages | 1985-04 | Callen Harty & Bryn Magnus | Bryn Magnus |
| Frankie N. Stein | 1985-05 | Danielle Dresden | Danielle Dresden |
| The Phantom of Shopppko | 1985-06 – Sept 7 – Nov 3 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Philoctetes | 1985-07 – November 15 – Dec 16 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Cherry Orchard | 1986-01 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Fatal Time to Final End | 1986-02 | Tracy Will | Tracy Will |
| Sodom or the Quintessence of Debauchery | 1986-03 – April 25 – June 1 | Joel Gersmann | John Wilmot, Earl of Rochester |
| Roar | 1986-04 | Marty Mulhern | Putu Wijaya |
| Breakfast for the World | 1986-05 | Rod Clark & Jennifer Bagnell | Rod Clark |
| The Hangwoman | 1986-06 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Tee-Vee Guide | 1987-01 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Park Bench | 1987-02 | Jennifer Bagnell & Williams Robinson | Williams Robinson & Jennifer Bagnell |
| Midnight in Moscow | 1987-03 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| My Own Sweet Game | 1987-04 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Long Way Home | 1987-05 – August 6 – august 30 Thurs-Sun 1987 | Jay Indik | Harry Schultz |
| Martian Time Slip | 1987-06 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann’s adaptation of Philip K. Dick novel |
| The Good Yuppie | 1987-07 | Joel Gersmann | Rod Clark |
| Creature Winds | 1988-01 | Renée Miller | Bryn Magnus |
| Nashinul Inquirer | 1988-02 – Mar 4 – April 10 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| D is for Danger | 1988-03 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Fat Zip | 1988-04 | Ron Daley | Paul Proch & Charles S. Kaufman |
| The Birds | 1988-05 | Marty Mulhern | Aristophanes |
| Joe, A Life | 1988-06 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Woods So Wild | 1988-07 | Douglas Frieden | Douglas Frieden & Chuck Pierson |
| Little Women | 1989-01 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Son of Jesus | 1989-02 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Everyperson | 1989-03 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann & Rod Clark |
| Secrets of Shorewood Bluff | 1989-04 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Heaven on Earth | 1989-05 | Joel Gersmann | Sharon Elder |
| Noah’s Arc | 1989-06 | Ron Daley | Mel Brenner |
| Mat Mania | 1989-07 | Paul Wells | Paul Wells & Steven Orlikowski |
| Ligeia has Risen From the Grave | 1990-01 | Joel Gersmann | Rod Clark |
| Hotel Queen | 1990-02 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Chicken and the Chicken Hawk | 1990-03 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Vampire Stewardesses from Hell | 1990-04 | Paul Wells | Paul Wells & Steven Orlikowski |
| Antony and Cleopatra | 1990-05 | Joel Gersmann | William Shakespeare |
| The Third Blackhawk War | 1990-06 | Ron Daley | Ron Daley |
| Attack of the Evil Greenheads | 1990-07 | Paul Wells | Ketrick Lehmann |
| Nashinull Inquirer Returns | 1991-01 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| How Soon is Now? | 1991-02 | Paul Wells | Paul Wells & Steven Orlikowski |
| The Grant | 1991-03 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Big Dick | 1991-04 | Paul Wells | Paul Wells |
| The Sitcom Family | 1991-05 | Marty Mulhern | Marty Mulhern |
| Badger Orpheus | 1991-06 | Ron Daley | Ron Daley |
| Hounds on the Hoof | 1991-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Hamlet Part 1 | 1992-01 | Joel Gersmann | William Shakespeare |
| Hamlet Part 2 | 1992-02 | Joel Gersmann | William Shakespeare |
| Iron Bitch | 1992-03 | Paul Wells | Paul Wells |
| Bon Voyage Brendan | 1992-04 | Marty Mulhern | Marty Mulhern |
| Die Lover, Die | 1992-05 | Catherine Dorl | Catherine Dorl |
| Come Back to the 7 11 Elvis Presley Elvis Presley | 1992-06 | Paul Wells | Paul Wells |
| My Fair Arab | 1992-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Dream Quest | 1993-01 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Peace of My Heart | 1993-02 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Twisted Sex Life of J. Edgar Hoover | 1993-03 | Paul Wells | Paul Wells |
| Sexy Priests | 1993-04 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Dr. Kevorkian’s Kountry Kitchen | 1993-05 | Paul Wells | Paul Wells |
| In The Matter of John David Hutchins | 1993-06 | Ron Daley | Ron Daley |
| Wuthering Heights (Hot Sex and Leather) | 1993-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Adventures of Ultrahman | 1994-01 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Real Live Sex on Stage | 1994-02 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Ulysses Won’t You Please Come Home | 1994-03 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Boys in the Basement | 1994-04 | Paul Wells | Paul Wells |
| Jack Nicholson Jack Nicholson | 1994-05 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Wizard of Oz | 1994-06 | Paul Wells | Paul Wells |
| The Case of the Nazi Professor | 1994-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Tales of the Chicken Legs: An Evening of Russian Folk Tales | 1995-01 | Nancy Streckert | Nancy Streckert (The Jester written by Marty Mulhern) |
| Devil in Paradise | 1995-02 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Mystery Play | 1995-03 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Unplugged: The Kurt Cobain Story | 1995-04 | Paul Wells | Paul Wells |
| I am Star Trek | 1995-05 | Rick Vorndran | Rick Vorndran |
| Buck Mulligan’s Revenge | 1995-06 | Marty Mulhern | Marty Mulhern |
| The Abortionist | 1995-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Let Her get On Top | 1996-01 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Legend of Pinkbeard: Pirate of Men | 1996-02 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Dr. Suess I Presume | 1996-03 | John Sable (Sabljak) | John Sable (Sabljak) |
| Cookies For My President | 1996-04 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Please Please Please Love Me | 1996-05 | Rick Vorndran | Rick Vorndran |
| Irish Lesbian Vampire | 1996-06 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Nazi Boy | 1996-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| My Favorite Alien | 1997-01 | Doug Banasky | Doug Banasky |
| Muffy the Bitch | 1997-02 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Sex Drugs Rock & Roll: The Real World | 1997-03 | John Sable (Sabljak) | John Sable (Sabljak) |
| The Three Sisters | 1997-04 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Tales for A Millennium | 1997-05 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| Michelangelo Renaissance P.I. | 1997-06 | Rick Vorndran | Rick Vorndran |
| Di Princess Di | 1997-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Yoshi’s Heroes | 1998-01 | Rob Matsushita | Rob Matsushita |
| Control Freaks in Love | 1998-02 | Rick Vorndran | Rick Vorndran |
| Miracle Play | 1998-03 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Walgen: A Man And His Sword | 1998-04 | Joe Weiner | Joe Weiner |
| Gay Like Me | 1998-05 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| How to Succeed in Business Without Really Dying | 1998-06 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| Make My Day: The Clint Eastwood Story | 1998-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Stiffy | 1999-01 | Ron Collins | Ron Collins |
| Pippi Long Stalking | 1999-02 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| 69 | 1999-03 | John Sable (Sabljak) | John Sable (Sabljak) |
| Pictures At an Exhibition | 1999-04 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Meeting Jerry Springer | 1999-05 | Rob Matsushita | Rob Matsushita |
| Trench Coat Mafia | 1999-06 | John Sable (Sabljak) | John Sable (Sabljak) |
| Breathless | 1999-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| What Ever Happened to Bette and Joan? | 2000-01 | Rob Matsushita | Rob Matsushita |
| That Trollope Woman | 2000-02 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| As You Like It -or- Free Tibet: The Musical | 2000-03 | John Sable (Sabljak) | Improv |
| The Color of Dust | 2000-04 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Sex Kittens From Mars | 2000-05 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| Irish Lesbian Vampire 2 | 2000-06 | Rob Matsushita | Rob Matsushita |
| The Three Musketeers | 2000-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| The Last Thief | 2001-01 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| The Ghost and Dr. Liz | 2001-02 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| Men Suck: the Amuse-icle | 2001-03 | John Sable (Sabljak) | John Sable (Sabljak) |
| FACEvalue | 2001-04 | Rob Matsushita | Rob Matsushita |
| Oklahomo | 2001-05 | Ron Collins | Ron Collins |
| Count Fagula | 2001-06 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Almost A Man | 2001-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Tales For A New Millennium | 2002-01 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| Judge | 2002-02 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Candyland You Slut | 2002-03 | John Sable (Sabljak) | John Sable (Sabljak) |
| My Four Fathers | 2002-04 | Scott Feiner | Scott Feiner |
| 10 Little Idiots | 2002-05 | Querida Funck | Querida Funck |
| Orange Murder Suit | 2002-06 | Rob Matsushita | Rob Matsushita |
| The Dumbass | 2002-07 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| The Man Who Loved Sex | 2003-01 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Silent Play | 2003-02 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Why Sex Why Not The Violin | 2003-03 | John Sable (Sabljak) | John Sable (Sabljak) |
| The Alabaster County Little League Beauty Pageant | 2003-04 | Scott Feiner | Scott Feiner |
| Psychos in Love | 2003-05 | Rob Matsushita | Rob Matsushita |
| Frankenstein-Shmankenstein | 2003-06 | Ron Collins | Ron Collins |
| The Ballerina and the Economist | 2003-07 | Joel Gersmann | Joel Gersmann |
| Oriphice | 2004-01 | Tracy Grzybowski | Matthew Grzybowski |
| The Altar Boy | 2004-02 | Brian Wild | Callen Harty |
| Untitled Farce | 2004-03 | Matthew Grzybowski | Matthew Grzybowski |
| Morality Play | 2004-04 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Audrey Seiler, Where Are You? | 2004-05 | John Sable (Sabljak) | John Sable (Sabljak) |
| Flowers for Dubya | 2004-06 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| Radical Harry | 2005-01 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Proper: The Series | 2005-02 | Matthew Grzybowski | Matthew Grzybowski |
| Sarah’s Spirits | 2005-03 | John Sable (Sabljak) | John Sable (Sabljak) |
| Oklahomo! | 2005-04 | Ron Collins | Ron Collins |
| Sledgehammer Party | 2005-05 | Rob Matsushita | Rob Matsushita |
| 667: Number of the Neighbor of the Beast | 2005-06 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| A Wake | 2006-01 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Fire Exit | 2006-02 | Greg Johnson | Greg Harris |
| Cows Gone Wild | 2006-03 | John Sable (Sabljak) | John Sable (Sabljak) |
| Melvin the Angry Magician | 2006-04 | Scott Feiner | Scott Feiner |
| Oh God, There’s Baptists at the Door | 2006-05 | Heather Renken | Heather Renken |
| Just Sit Right Back and You’ll Hear a Tale | 2006-06 | Doug Reed | Doug Reed |
| A Very Bitchy Christmas | 2006-07 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| Debs in Prison | 2007-01 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Dancing in Cleo’s Cafe | 2007-02 | Brian J. Belz | Cassi Harris |
| Dr. Faustus | 2007-03 | Greg Johnson | Christopher Marlowe |
| Why We Come Here | 2007-04 | Terry Lane | Megan McGlone |
| Vogue | 2007-05 | Matt Kenyon | Ron Collins |
| Funnel | 2007-06 | Ethan Mutz | Ethan Mutz |
| Dork Side of the Moon | 2007-07 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| The Maple Bluff Mystery | 2008-01 | Scott Rawson | Scott Rawson |
| Leprechaun | 2008-02 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Multiple O | 2008-03 | John Sable (Sabljak) | John Sable (Sabljak) |
| For What It’s Worth | 2008-04 | Cassi Harris | Cassi Harris |
| Shiny Things | 2008-05 | Heather Renken | Heather Renken |
| Run Faggot Run | 2008-06 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| Dancing With My Other | 2008-07 | Lauri Harty | Kathie Rassmussen |
| A Wake | 2009-01 | Matt Kenyon | Callen Harty |
| The birds that are your hands | 2009-02 | Sol Kelly-Jones | Sol Kelly-Jones |
| Where Were You When You Were Stolen? | 2009-03 | John Sable (Sabljak) | Ron Fisher & John Sabljak |
| Lounging Around | 2009-04 | Ben Doran | Siobhan Edge |
| Minglewood Blues | 2009-05 | Marty Mulhurn | Doug Reed |
| Tales From the Dork Side | 2009-06 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| McBeth | 2009-07 | Greg Johnson | William Shakespeare, contemporized by Callen Harty |
| Cattywompus | 2010-01 | Christina Beller | Christina Beller & Justin Lawfer |
| The Wake of Liam Doherty | 2010-02 | Ndig0 | Siobhan Edge |
| Multiple O: The Second Coming | 2010-03 | John Sable (Sabljak) | John Sable (Sabljak) |
| Television: The Play | 2010-04 | Amanda Jones | Amanda Jones |
| A Woman On Paper | 2010-06 | Heather Renken | Heather Renken |
| Invisible Boy | 2010-07 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Yoo-hoo, Rent-A-Cop, and the Ambulance Chaser’s Bitch | 2010-08 | Ethan Mutz | Ethan Mutz |
| Maya & Me | 2011-01 | Kay Dixon | Kay Dixon |
| Riverwest: A Rhapsody | 2011-02 | Eric Theis | Eric Theis |
| Hitler Was Right (The German Shepherd Is A Great Dog!• He Loved DOGS!) And Other Plays | 2011-03 | Rob Matsushita | Rob Matsushita |
| Myth America | 2011-04 | Matt Kenyon | Callen Harty |
| The Lamentable Tragedie of Scott Walker Governour of Wisconsin | 2011-05 | Doug Reed | Doug Reed |
| A Broom Street Halloween | 2011-06 | Brian Wild | Paula Duerksen, Jeff Duerksen, Callen Harty, Rob Matsushita, Scott Rawson, Laszlo Reed Doug Reed, Brian Wild & the cast of A Broom Street Halloween |
| The Ghosts Of Christmas Past | 2011-07 | Christina Beller & Scott Rawson | Christina Beller & Scott Rawson |
| On the Corner of Clark and Vine | 2012-01 | Autumn Shiley | Autumn Shiley |
| Splendor in the Math | 2012-02 | Scott Feiner | Scott Feiner |
| Iceland | 2012-03 | Collin Erickson & Heather Renken | Micheal Tooher |
| 900 | 2012-04 | Rob Matsushita | Rob Matsushita |
| Tracks: A Cycle in Two Plays | 2012-05 | Christopher Younggren | Christopher Younggren |
| Rubbery with Violets, Or, If You Can See This, Thank Your Optician | 2012-06 | Jan Levine-Thal | Siobhan Edge |
| Pericles | 2012-07 | Greg Harris | William Shakespeare |
| One Man/One Woman, A Comedy About Marriage Equality | 2012-08 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| Seeking Flight | 2012-09 | Malissa Lamont & Heather Renken | Joan Broadman |
| Tales for Another Millennium | 2012-10 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| Class | 2013-01 | Tyler Falco Schott | Coleman |
| Not the Artist | 2013-02 | Heather Renken | Kurt Mc Ginnis Brown |
| Superhero Boogie | 2013-03 | Rob Matsushita | Rob Matsushita |
| Orphan Train | 2013-04 | Lindsey Hoel Neds | Deanna Reed |
| Lekker Mann | 2013-05 | Tracy M. Smith | Tracy M. Smith |
| The Waiting Room | 2013-06 | Odari Kimani | Michael Tooher |
| Triggered | 2013-07 | Callen Harty | Callen Harty |
| The Sweet Lowdown | 2013-08 | John Siewert (Two Diabetics), Donald Dexter (The Sweet Lowdown) | Matt DeFour (Two Diabetics), Mary Fairweather Dexter (The Sweet Lowdown) |
| Cassandra’s Gift | 2013-09 | Jan Levine-Thal | Jan Levine-Thal |
| Requiem for a Dungeon Master | 2014-01 | Scott Feiner | Scott Feiner |
| Chat | 2014-02 | Dan Myers | Dan Myers |
| W8ing 4 G-Dogg | 2014-03 | Matt Kenyon | Brendan Hartmann |
| Glasshole! | 2014-04 | Eric Holz | Eric Holz |
| Civil | 2014-05 | Rob Matsushita | Rob Matsushita |
| Nottingham! | 2014-06 | Heather Renken | Doug Reed |
| Delicious Festival At Broom Street | 2014-07 | Various | Various |
| A Matter Of Legacy | 2014-08 | Malissa Petterson | Malissa Petterson (Music by Ceridwen Pietras & Jennie Huntoon) |
| Gingerbreadcrumbs | 2014-09 | Suzan Kurry | Christopher Youngren |
| Finding Human | 2015-01 | Dan Myers | Dan Myers |
| Ten Dollar House | 2015-02 | John Siewert | Rick Kinnebrew & Martha Meyer |
| Greetings From Fitzwalkerstan | 2015-03 | Odari Kimani | Brian Leahy Doyle (music by Michael Dilthey & Brian Leahy Doyle) |
| The Nails | 2015-04 | Rob Matsushita | Doug Reed |
| Held | 2015-05 | Kelly Maxwell | Kelly Maxwell (book and lyrics) & Meghan Rose (music) |
| Pudding | 2015-06 | Eric Holz | Michael Tooher |
| Bite The Apple | 2015-07 | Malissa Petterson | Malissa Petterson |
| Invasion Of The Jesus Snatchers | 2015-08 | Brian Wild | Brian Wild |
| Big Expectations | 2015-08 | Ray Olderman | Ray Olderman |
| Are We Delicious Xmas ’15 | 2015-09 | Tony Trout | Various |
| The 800th Annual Salvation Swing-Off | 2016-01 | Malissa Petterson | Malissa Petterson |
| Monster Boogie | 2016-02 | Rob Matsushita | Rob Matsushita |
| Sweet William | 2016-03 | Doug Reed | Doug Reed |
| Spread The Nudes | 2016-04 | Chris Holoyda | Chris Holoyda |
| Bar Games | 2016-05 | Dan Myers | Dan Myers |
| Black & White | 2016-06 | HJ Farr | Kip Price |
| Esthers Descendants | 2016-07 | Jan Levine Thal | Jan Levine Thal |
| Playscapes | 2016-08 | Kelly Maxwell & Amber McReynolds | Kelly Maxwell |
| The Undertow | 2016-09 | John Siewert | Michael Tooher |
| The Full Treatment | 2017-01 | Jay Shearer | Doug Reed |
| Richard II | 2017-02 | Christopher William Wolter | William Shakespeare |
| Dumpster Flower | 2017-03 | Malissa Petterson | Malissa Petterson |
| Geppetto | 2017-04 | Stephen Murray | Stephen Murray |
| Dick Pix Montana | 2017-05 | Chris Holoyda | Chris Holoyda |
| Her Dream, A Pen, and A Book | 2017-06 | Morganna Grim | Morganna Grim |
| Are We Delicious: Persisted/Bacchae | 2017-07 | Malissa Petterson & Tony Trout | Various |
| Corruption Ball | 2017-08 | John Siewert | Kip Price |
| Antigone | 2018-01 | Christopher William Wolter | Slavoj Žižek |
| Menace To Society: A Mormon In Milwaukee | 2018-02 | Doug Reed | Lisa Sipos |
| Imogen(s) | 2018-03 | Niccole Carner | Christopher William Wolter |
| Are We Delicious: SPRUNG! | 2018-04 | Trevin Gay | Various |
| A Contest Of Wills | 2018-05 | Matthew Korda | Coleman |
| The Vapors | 2018-06 | Malissa Petterson | Malissa Petterson |
| All For One! The Three Musketeers Musical | 2018-07 | Tony Trout & Brandon Jensen | David Durbin, Kelly Maxwell, Doug Reed, Matt Sloan & Tony Trout |
| Unpresidented | 2018-09 | Maria Dahman | Philip Heckman, Dwayne Yancey,Phillip Kaplan, Jess Schuknecht, Rob Matsushita, Seth McNeill, Amber McReynolds, Doug Reed & Gwendolyn Rice |
| Are We Delicious: Notorious Damsels | 2018-10 | Malissa Petterson | HJ Farr, Bree Prehn, Stacey Garbarski, Erica Hagen & Heather Renken |
| Hemidemisemiquavers | 2019-01 | Doug Reed & Suzan Kurry | L.A. Green, John Lennon, Doug Reed, Mark Harvey Levine, Scott Mullen & Dan Toomey |
| Prom | 2019-02 | Kathy Lynn Sliter & Isabella Anastasia Leigh | Rob Matsushita |
| Best Friends Stab You (In The Front) | 2019-03 | Molly Vanderlin | Gina M. Gomez |
| Lysistrata | 2019-04 | Jen Plants | Aristophanes |
| Sister Girl | 2019-05 | Janine Gardner | Prudence Wright Holmes |
| The Widowmaker | 2019-06 | Malissa Petterson | Malissa Petterson |
| Half | 2019-07 | Maria Dahman | Doug Reed |
| Keep It!: Plucked from the Corpus of Joel Gersmann | 2019-08 | Scott Feiner | Joel Gersmann & Scott Feiner |
| Hamilton: The Original 1917 Broadway Smash Hit | 2019-09 | Doug Reed | Mary P. Hamlin & George Arliss |
| Hark! A Lark! | 2020-01 | John Siewert | John Siewert |
| Geneology | 2021-01 | Dana Pellebon | T.J. Elliott and Joe Queenan |
| Laconia | 2022-01 | Doug Reed | Christa Dahman Zaborske,Taylor Kokinos, Maria Dahman, Brent Holmes, Doug Reed |
| Happy Landings | 2022-02 | Jan Levine Thal | Pamela Monk |
| The Guest Book | 2022-03 | Gina M. Gomez | Gina M. Gomez |
| The Little Death | 2022 04 | Malissa Petterson | Malissa Petterson |
| The Totally Not Haunted Backstage Tour Where Nothing Can Possibly Go Tragically Awry | 2022 05 | Ilsa Reed | Doug Reed |
| The Abortionist: A Woman Against the Law | 2023-01 | Scott Feiner | Joel Gersmann and Scott Feiner |
| It’s All Overboard | 2023-02 | Maria Dahman | Lisa Sipos |
| An Evening of the Absurd | 2023-03 | Matt Gryzbowski | Matt Gryzbowski |
| Our Home States (Midwest Edition) | 2023-04 | Jan Levine Thal, Kathleen Tissot, Brent Holmes, Bernie Hein, Robyn Norton | Doug Reed, Maria Dahman, Maripat Allen, Allison Fradkin, Alex Goldberg, Claudia Haas, Marisa Kahler, Jean Koppen, Rex McGregor, James McLindon, Kathleen Allison Johnson |
| Paul Blart 3: Blart Of Darkness | 2023-05 | Doug Reed | Alan Talaga |
Broom Street Theater